Policy Comparison’s – Pierce

New Auto Owners Policy

Homeowners

Dwelling : $639,300
Other Structures : $63,930 plus additional
$120,000 for shed
Personal Property : $466,500
Loss of Use: $127,860
Personal Liability : $500,000
Medical Payments: $5,000

Other coverages:
Guaranteed replacement cost on dwelling
Family Cyber Protection
Water backup coverage/sump failure - $15,000
Equipment breakdown coverage up to $100,000
Service Line Coverage - $15,000
Scheduled Jewelry

Deductible: $1000 All other perils $2,000 wind/hail

$1,299.28

Auto

Bodily Injury Liability and Property Damage
$250,000 per person; $500,000 per accident
$100,000 Property damage

Medical Payments: $10,000

Uninsured Motorist:
$250,000 per person; $500,000 per accident

Under-insured Motorist:
$250,000 per person; $500,000 per accident

Comprehensive coverage - $500 all vehicles
Collision Coverage - $500 all vehicles

Towing/roadside assistance both vehicles
Rental/extended transport - $40/day $1200 limit both vehicles

$994.37

Umbrella

$1,000,000 liability

$271

Total Combined Premium

$2,564.65

vs.

Progressive Proposal

Homeowners

Dwelling : $601,000
Other Structures : $120,200
Personal Property : $420,700
Loss of Use: $60,100
Personal Liability : $500,000
Medical Payments: $1,000

Other coverages:
Water backup/sump pump failure - $10,000
50% increase replacement cost dwelling
Scheduled Jewelry
Identity Management service

Deductible: $1,000

$1,250

Auto

$490 per 6 months or $980 per year

Umbrella

$1,000,000 liability

$318

Total Combined Premium

$2,548

★★★★★

General notes:

Overall policies are quite similar as they stand. My homeowner’s proposal has a couple more added optional coverages such as equipment breakdown and service line coverage which I do believe are great coverages to have. I do know that Progressive home offers these coverages as well but don’t see them listed. I also have $15,000 in water backup coverage vs the $10,000 on Progressive quote. The auto is extremely close in everything. Biggest difference is Progressive 6-month policy vs my quote is a 12-month policy. With a 6-month policy your policy will be re-rated every 6 months vs a year so the likelihood of the premium staying exactly the same on the renewal to make the 12-month comparison is very slim so the Progressive 12-month total would likely be slightly higher. We have also been noticing in our own book of business that Progressive home renewals are jumping in premium after the first year for whatever reason usually due to their discount structures.