WELCOME TO THE ALL NEW COMMUNITY INSURANCE!

If you're looking for a local, independent insurance agent in Wisconsin we're the only agency you need. To get started, enter your information on our website here or call us direct.

HERE'S WHY HUNDREDS OF WISCONSIN RESIDENTS CHOOSE OUR AGENCY:

Unlike captive and direct insurance companies who often hard-sell proprietary products and coverages, Community Insurance is different because we are 100% independent of any one company.

 

We have access to a wide range of some of the highest rated insurance companies in the country, and we provide customer service that you can only get from a team of people who truly care about protecting you and your family, and possessions.

 

We do the heavy lifting for you

What's more, you don't have to lift a finger. We'll take your current coverage and provide you with a detailed comparison, showing you all of your available coverage and pricing options.

AUTO
HOME
BUSINESS
BOAT
MOTORCYCLE
LIFE
BIZ AUTO
WORK COMP
RENTERS

REAL FEEDBACK FROM OUR AWESOME CUSTOMERS!

Ken & Barb Konkol

Personal Insurance Customer

After 10 years of auto, home, umbrella, and commercial rental insurance coverage through Community Insurance & Associates Agency, we would highly recommend them for all your insurance needs.

Kimberlin

Personal Insurance Customer

We are very satisfied with the help we get for our insurance needs. Couldn’t ask for better service! Thank you so much.

Beth & Dale

Personal Insurance Customer

When the unthinkable happens and your roof blows off in an early spring storm, knowing that you have an agent to call is an immeasurable asset. Our agent Gail Huberty has provided us with absolutly outstanding service.

Jeremy Sherf

Personal Insurance Customer

Community Insurance has great customer service and always there in time of need.

GET STARTED ONLINE IN SECONDS

We'll shop and compare for you, saving you time, aggravation, and money!

Choice

Being Independent means that we don't work for any one insurance company. We have the ability to search multiple companies on your behalf, acting as a negotiator, to find you the best possible policy and price. You never have to haggle with an agent or insurance company again.

Expertise

Not all insurance agencies are created equal. We have an in-depth knowledge of insurance policy coverages from dozens of different insurance companies. We've seen it all, and when it comes to fine print, we truly understand the coverage we are recommending.

Service

Why sit on hold with a call center representative who doesn't know you, when you can deal with a familiar face who knows you and understands your unique situation? Our customer service is the single biggest reason why our customers refer us so many of their friends.

Claims

The entire reason you have insurance is for when you need to use it. Unfortunately, insurance contracts contain many exclusions and conditions you may be unaware of. We'll help you understand how you're covered, and walk you through your claim.

Local

When you do business with our agency, you're not only supporting your local community, but you're being serviced by a local business who knows your name, and your unique coverage needs. You never have to deal with call-center representatives again.

WHY CHOOSE COMMUNITY INSURANCE?

Choosing the right insurance policy can be a daunting task even for a well informed consumer. At Community Insurance, our main goal is the make the process as easy and enjoyable as possible.

 

One of the biggest reasons you would want to use an independent agent like us, is we work and live in your community. We provide all of our customers with a personalized customer experience.

 

You're never just a number at Community Insurance!

ANSWERS TO FREQUENTLY ASKED INSURANCE QUESTIONS

Insurance is one of the most confusing things for the average consumer to understand – but it doesn't have to be that way. At Community Insurance, we take great pride in educating you on how your coverage works.

 

This is critical in ensuring that you know exactly what you're paying for when you purchase insurance from us, or any other agency. Insurance is a legally binding contract between you, and an insurance company. It's important that you understand how you're covered, how you're not covered, and what the conditions are in your policy.

GET STARTED ONLINE IN SECONDS

We'll shop and compare for you, saving you time, aggravation, and money!

  • Some days you just need some ice cream!

#morethanjustinsurance1
  • Who doesn’t love gifts from local clients! #communityiswhatwedo #morethanjustinsurance3
  • Holiday team party! #morethanjustinsurance3
  • #communityiswhatwedo #morethanjustinsurance5
  • Phil from our Amherst Office had his grandson helping to deliver pajamas our team members donated!7
  • #ilovesecura #charitychallenge2
  • We can’t wait to see who wins a $1,000 the end of December for referring new clients to our office! We ❤️ referrals! #ilovesecura #charitychallenge #thereisstilltimetorefer #thereisstilltimetowin6
  • #ilovesecura #charitychallenge11
  • New business cards and new mugs?! #micdrop #ilovesecura #charitychallenge8
  • Stop in for a new pen or carpenter pencil! #ilovesecura #charitychallenge4
  • It feels #write to be a #customer with @community_ins!6
  • #newbusinesscards but don’t worry, it’s still us! @mrsblenker9
Call Email Quote Like Us